I am paying $30/month for managed WordPress hosting (Cloudways) for one client site. A Hetzner VPS could run the same site for $5/month. But I would need to handle updates, security, backups, and monitoring myself.
Has anyone done the math on what DIY server management actually costs in time?
For a single site, managed hosting is usually worth the premium. The time you spend on server management adds up:
- Initial setup: 2-4 hours
- Monthly maintenance (updates, monitoring checks): 1-2 hours
- Incident response when something breaks: unpredictable, 0-8 hours/month
At even a low rate of $50/hour, one incident per month makes the VPS more expensive than Cloudways.
The math changes when you have 10+ sites on one VPS. Then the management time is amortized and DIY wins.
I manage 30 sites on two Hetzner VPSs. Total cost about $15/month. I spend maybe 3-4 hours per month on maintenance, most of which is automated (unattended upgrades, automated backups, monitoring alerts).
The key is investing time upfront in automation. Once your server is properly configured with automated backups, updates, and monitoring, the ongoing maintenance is minimal.